How the oud grading systems line up — and where they do not
The grade systems a buyer meets are not one scale in different clothes: a seller's ordering, a density screen, a measured resin figure, a national label, a Japanese or Chinese auction category and a lab profile are six different kinds of claim. This page maps each one and says what it does and does not establish, so two different kinds are never mistaken for a comparison.
Direct Answer & Executive Summary
The systems do not line up because they are not measuring the same thing, and that is the point the page exists to make. A Gulf "Super" label is a seller's ordering of the material; a sinking grade is a physical screen that tells you the wood is dense and says nothing about the resin behind it; a resin-recovery figure is the one of the six that is actually a measurement; a national gaharu grade is a domestic label on its own scale; a Japanese or Chinese auction category is a local ritual convention; and a lab profile is a chemical description of what is present, not of where it came from or how old it is. A buyer who reads each one as the kind of claim it is, and refuses to average across kinds, can read every one of them correctly — and the moment two of them are treated as comparable, the reading is wrong.
Six systems, six kinds of claim
The first move is to stop treating the grade word as a single thing. The buyer meets six systems, and each is a different kind of claim: a seller's ordering of lots, a physical density screen, a measured resin figure, a national label, a local auction convention, and a chemical profile. They share a vocabulary but not a meaning. The Gulf "Super" series and the VIP and VVIP rungs order material the way a seller does, on aroma alone, with no published step between one rung and the next. Sinking tells you the wood is dense, and nothing more. Resin recovery is the one number that is a measurement, with the uncertainty the review records attached to it. The national scales run on their own numbering. The Japanese and Chinese categories are the way a particular market grades material for its own use. And the lab reports what is in the material. Hold that list, and the whole reconciliation is just reading each one as its kind.
The systems and what each one does not establish
Each system is named and its boundary stated, so a buyer knows where the claim ends:
- The Gulf Super series and the VIP–VVIP rungs: a seller's ordering on aroma. They set no resin content, no yield and no age, and two lots so labelled by different sellers need not be comparable.
- Sinking / density grades: a physical screen. The wood is dense; that is all it says. It does not establish the resin content, its naturalness or its age, and a weighted block passes the test for the same reason a genuine one does.
- Resin-recovery figures: the one measured quantity of the six, read with the uncertainty the review records. A figure is a measurement, not a grade; the review attaches no threshold to it.
- National scales (the Indonesian gaharu grades against the Malaysian count): domestic labels, on their own numbering, not on a shared scale — a label from one market is not a position on another market's ladder.
- Japanese and Chinese auction categories (the rikkoku classification around the trade word for agarwood): a local convention, not a specification; a buyer outside that market reads the category as a local label, not as a measurable grade.
- The laboratory profile: a chemical description of what is present. It does not establish species, origin, age or wild-versus-plantation; a clean profile is a profile, not an authentication of the lot.
Where the systems do not compare
The failure the page exists to stop is the false comparison: reading a density figure, a "Super" label and a national gaharu grade as if they were three measurements of one quality, and averaging them. They are not three measurements of one thing, and only one of the three is a measurement at all. A lot that is "sinking", labelled "Super", and quoted from the Japanese auction is carrying three different kinds of claim in one sentence, and no combination of the three establishes a measured grade — because no two of the three are on the same scale. The move is to name the kind of each one before the kinds are set against one another. A label the seller put there is a claim, not a fact. A screen is a screen. A measured number is a number, with the uncertainty it carries. A national or a Japanese category is a label on its own market's own scale. And the whole point is that a buyer who holds those apart reads every one of them correctly, and a buyer who averages them has drawn a conclusion the systems never license.
This page reconciles the systems a buyer meets and states what each does and does not establish. It is not a grading standard and it does not publish a threshold, recovery rate or yield for any label, because the record is that none is published behind them. The national-scale counts it names are the industry's own review's record, not a cross-market measurement. No combination of these systems is presented as establishing a grade: the reconciliation is that they are different kinds of claim, and the page does not measure a lot, authenticate a lot, or compare a figure across systems it says are not on the same scale.
Verification Bibliography
Table 1 lists the accepted Aquilaria and Gyrinops species with their IUCN Red List status and their range states, drawn from the IUCN Red List, the cited 2021 and 2022 species assessments, and the Kew Plants of the World Online checklist. The summary establishes that all members of both genera (at least 28 species) are in CITES Appendix II, that A. malaccensis was listed in 1995 and the other species were added in 2005, that the major Aquilaria exporters are Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand, that more than 98% of the material exported from Malaysia and Indonesia is wild stock while the wood from Thailand is all plantation origin, that the main Gyrinops exporters are Indonesia (including Papua) and Sri Lanka, that plantation agarwood is reported to be of inferior quality and worth less than wild material, and that the global industry has been estimated at more than USD 30 billion with a litre of oil at USD 40,000-50,000. It also states the grading systems in use (Malaysia twelve grades, Indonesia nine, a separate Chinese guide), that the industry still lacks a global grading standard based on quantifiable indicators, and that the taxonomy of the two genera is not settled and requires reassessment. It does not establish the quality or grade of any individual lot, does not establish the price of any particular material, and does not establish that material from a given range state was produced there rather than traded through it.
States that CITES Appendix II covers all species of Aquilaria and Gyrinops, and reports fifteen Aquilaria species distributed across the tropical and subtropical regions of Asia, from Pakistan and India through southern China into Southeast Asia. It does not establish the legal status of any individual shipment in any particular jurisdiction.
A 2010 study of the agarwood trade and use in the United Arab Emirates, based on interviews with traders, the UAE CITES authorities, Dubai customs and retail survey work. It establishes the import and re-export structure: the UAE and Saudi Arabia are the two dominant Middle Eastern markets; Saudi Arabia is the largest recipient of agarwood re-exported from the UAE, followed by Kuwait and Qatar, which is the entrepôt role the UAE plays; the UAE market has no registered association of importers or traders and little information exchange between companies; the UAE CITES Annual Report submissions began in 2004 and reported chip imports rose from over 56 tonnes in 2004 to more than 162 tonnes in 2007; a CITES export permit is required before a CITES-listed product such as agarwood may be imported, and a UAE import permit is also required; the customs treatment applies a 5% duty on the value of agarwood imports where a customs officer detects them. It also records that the same grade from different origins may carry different value in the market, and gives the 2005-2007 retail price ranges per kilogram in AED. The study is dated 2010 and its price data is from 2005-2007, so it establishes market structure and the import-control regime rather than any current price or current volume. It does not establish who may legally ship into any particular market today, and it does not establish the quality or authenticity of any material.
Rejaul Karim · Lead Perfumery & Agarwood Sourcing Researcher · 2026-10-20
Reviewed against the cited sources, checked for a question-specific answer, and checked that every assurance is either sourced or explicitly marked as a limitation.
- Read one system: how a grading claim is built
- Read the density screen on its own: what it does and does not do
- Read the one measured quantity: resin and its uncertainty
- Read the Gulf label vocabulary and its dataset
Need commercial volume or bulk samples?
OudGuide provides a neutral matching service. A redacted brief reaches qualified suppliers without your identity, and your contact details are released only to a supplier you approve by name.
Submit a wholesale requirement