The OudGuide oud authenticity protocol
The five checks a buyer can run on a lot of oud, in a fixed order — resin, density, burn, scent persistence and price — and, read separately, the one laboratory test and the one document that actually carry evidence. What each step establishes, what it does not, and how to read the results together.
Direct Answer & Executive Summary
The practical way to check a lot of oud is to run five physical checks in a fixed order — look at the resin, test the density, burn a sample, judge the scent persistence, and set the price against the documented range for the claimed grade — and then, read on their own, the two instruments that actually carry evidence: the laboratory test and the conservation paperwork. The five checks are signals, not a verdict: each establishes a narrow thing, and a capable counterfeiter can pass all five. The laboratory test is the only check that can say what the material is. The paperwork is the only statement where a false claim has a legal consequence. No single step authenticates the lot; the protocol is the ordered set of questions a capable supplier can answer and a careless one cannot.
Run the checks in a fixed order
The order matters because each later check tells you how to read the earlier ones. Start with the resin, because a non-resinous piece is not in the running at all, and because the resin is what every other check is measuring a proxy for. Then density, then the burn, then scent persistence, then price. A buyer who runs the price check first has already decided what the lot is and will bend the physical evidence to fit it; the fixed order keeps the physical evidence leading the price question rather than the reverse. It is also the order in which a competent supplier expects to be asked, which is itself a test: a supplier who will not be answered in the order is telling you something before the first check has run.
Step one: the resin, visually
Resin content is the property the whole trade prices, and the visual is the only check a buyer can do without burning anything. Look for the dark bands, the heavier hand, and the way the resin sits in the grain. A piece with visible resin is resinous, which is necessary: it tells you the material is in the class you are buying. It is not sufficient: an adulterated or blended piece will show resin and still be misrepresented in grade or origin. The visual cannot measure the resin, name the species, or say whether the piece is genuine agarwood or a resin-stained imitation. It sets the floor of the question, not its answer.
Step two: the density, and what it does not prove
A sinking test measures density, which is a correlate of resin content, not a measure of it. Dense material holds more resin, so the sink tells you the material is resinous in degree; it does not tell you it is agarwood rather than a dense imitation, and it does not name the species or the origin. A counterfeiter can add a dense resin or a dense filler and pass the test, which is why the density check must never be the last word. Take the result the test gives — the material is heavier or lighter than the class it is sold in — and carry it forward as one of several signals, not as the verdict.
Step three: the burn
The burn is the field test buyers actually run, because a lot is not going to be sent to a laboratory for every purchase. A sample is burned and the buyer judges the smoke, the residue, and the scent it throws off as it burns and after it cools. The burn separates the material that burns cleanly and scatters a persistent resin scent from the material that burns like wood, leaves a greasy or ashy residue, or gives a flat, short scent. It is a strong signal, but it is still the buyer's own judgement: it tells you about the behaviour of the material in front of you, not its identity. A well-made imitation will burn like oud; the burn does not name the material, and a seller cannot re-run it identically after you have broken off the sample.
Step four: scent persistence
Once the sample has cooled, the persistence of the scent is the check a fragrance buyer leans on, and the one most often used to cut corners. A resinous piece scatters a scent that lingers on the skin and in the room; a thin, resinated-but-weak piece fades quickly, and an oil-injected or blended piece can smell flat or greasy. Persistence tells you about concentration and about the character of the material; it does not authenticate it. A blend of a cheap oil into a resinated filler can pass a persistence check that a buyer reads as "it keeps going," and the only check that separates the two is the laboratory, which is why persistence is step four and not the answer.
Step five: the price, read against the documented range
The price is the check that ties the whole set of claims together, and the strongest single signal that one of them is false. The trade has a documented range — the observation baseline in this guide records it — for a claimed grade in a given market and form, and a price below that range means one of the two claims is false: the grade is lower than stated, or the material is not what it is called. A capable supplier answers which, and names the basis; a careless one does not. The price does not by itself say the lot is real; it says that a claim is being pressed. Read it with the four physical results, and use the document and the laboratory to close whatever the price has opened.
The two instruments that carry evidence on their own
Two instruments sit outside the five signals and must be read separately. The laboratory test — chromatography and mass spectrometry, in the trade's usage — is the only check that can say what the material is, in the sense that no physical signal can; it names the compounds present. It does not name the species, the age or the origin of the lot, and a clean report does not authenticate the lot, because a sample can be substituted for what was purchased. The conservation paperwork is the only statement where a false claim has a consequence: every agarwood-producing species is in the trade's Appendix II listing, so a legal import carries an export or re-export permit, and the permit is a statement the issuing authority is accountable for. The two are checked separately from the physical signals, and a lot can pass the five checks and still fail one of these two, or pass both and still be misrepresented in marketing.
This is a hypothetical example, not a real transaction. A buyer is offered a lot described as "wild, super grade" at a price near the bottom of the documented range for that grade. The supplier will run a burn and a sinking test on request.
- Run the five in order: resin visual, density, burn, persistence, price — not price first.
- Read the price against the range: near the bottom of the range for a claimed "super grade" means the grade claim or the material claim is false; ask which, and the basis.
- Ask the supplier to run the burn on the sample the buyer holds, not on a substitute the supplier keeps.
- Check the two evidence instruments separately: what the laboratory test would say about the material, and what the paperwork says about the lot that actually moved.
- Hold the verdict: five passed signals plus a failed evidence instrument is a "do not buy," because the signals can be passed by a counterfeiter and the evidence cannot be bent.
The example shows the method, not a verdict: the ordered signals, the price read against the range, and the two evidence instruments checked separately. It does not say what this lot is worth and it does not say the lot is real or not real.
This protocol is OudGuide's ordered synthesis of the checks a buyer can run alone; it is not a published standard, and no authority certifies it as such. The five physical checks are heuristic signals that a capable counterfeiter can pass, and only the laboratory test and the conservation paperwork carry evidence on their own. It does not authenticate any specific lot, does not name the species, age or origin of any lot, and does not establish that any named seller is or is not fraudulent. The price range it refers to is the observation baseline's documented range on a stated date and market, not a market average and not a price guide.
Verification Bibliography
Table 1 lists the accepted Aquilaria and Gyrinops species with their IUCN Red List status and their range states, drawn from the IUCN Red List, the cited 2021 and 2022 species assessments, and the Kew Plants of the World Online checklist. The summary establishes that all members of both genera (at least 28 species) are in CITES Appendix II, that A. malaccensis was listed in 1995 and the other species were added in 2005, that the major Aquilaria exporters are Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand, that more than 98% of the material exported from Malaysia and Indonesia is wild stock while the wood from Thailand is all plantation origin, that the main Gyrinops exporters are Indonesia (including Papua) and Sri Lanka, that plantation agarwood is reported to be of inferior quality and worth less than wild material, and that the global industry has been estimated at more than USD 30 billion with a litre of oil at USD 40,000-50,000. It also states the grading systems in use (Malaysia twelve grades, Indonesia nine, a separate Chinese guide), that the industry still lacks a global grading standard based on quantifiable indicators, and that the taxonomy of the two genera is not settled and requires reassessment. It does not establish the quality or grade of any individual lot, does not establish the price of any particular material, and does not establish that material from a given range state was produced there rather than traded through it.
States that CITES Appendix II covers all species of Aquilaria and Gyrinops, and reports fifteen Aquilaria species distributed across the tropical and subtropical regions of Asia, from Pakistan and India through southern China into Southeast Asia. It does not establish the legal status of any individual shipment in any particular jurisdiction.
A 2010 study of the agarwood trade and use in the United Arab Emirates, based on interviews with traders, the UAE CITES authorities, Dubai customs and retail survey work. It establishes the import and re-export structure: the UAE and Saudi Arabia are the two dominant Middle Eastern markets; Saudi Arabia is the largest recipient of agarwood re-exported from the UAE, followed by Kuwait and Qatar, which is the entrepôt role the UAE plays; the UAE market has no registered association of importers or traders and little information exchange between companies; the UAE CITES Annual Report submissions began in 2004 and reported chip imports rose from over 56 tonnes in 2004 to more than 162 tonnes in 2007; a CITES export permit is required before a CITES-listed product such as agarwood may be imported, and a UAE import permit is also required; the customs treatment applies a 5% duty on the value of agarwood imports where a customs officer detects them. It also records that the same grade from different origins may carry different value in the market, and gives the 2005-2007 retail price ranges per kilogram in AED. The study is dated 2010 and its price data is from 2005-2007, so it establishes market structure and the import-control regime rather than any current price or current volume. It does not establish who may legally ship into any particular market today, and it does not establish the quality or authenticity of any material.
Establishes that all species of Aquilaria and Gyrinops have been listed in CITES Appendix II since 2004, and that the listing followed unsustainable extraction. Establishes that the report reviews wild and planted agarwood resources, processing technologies, products and regulatory practices, and that cultivation and inoculation of agarwood species are described as relieving pressure on wild populations in natural forests. It does not state what an Appendix II listing requires for trade, and it does not establish the origin, age or quality of any material.
Rejaul Karim · Lead Perfumery & Agarwood Sourcing Researcher · 2026-10-20
Reviewed against the cited sources, checked for a question-specific answer, and checked that every assurance is either sourced or explicitly marked as a limitation.
- Press the grade claims first: learn how grading claims work
- Understand what the one document that actually constrains the trade states
- See why a clean laboratory report still does not authenticate a lot
Need commercial volume or bulk samples?
OudGuide provides a neutral matching service. A redacted brief reaches qualified suppliers without your identity, and your contact details are released only to a supplier you approve by name.
Submit a wholesale requirement